Marquis Davis

From Echo Chambers to Common Ground: The Imperative of Collaboration in a Diverse World

Escaping an echo chamber takes more than exposure to competing views. It takes a concrete problem and a reason to solve it with someone else.

Two profiles in conversation at a shared table.

Listening is a step toward doing

Media and social platforms can make it easy to hear the same reading of an event from everyone we follow. Over time, we can lose the ability to explain what somebody outside that circle actually thinks. We learn how to respond to a version of their argument prepared by our own side.

Acknowledging that people are different is a beginning. The more demanding task is letting somebody’s knowledge change what you do. A resident, a small business owner and a public official may all care about the same commercial block while seeing different problems on it. Harsh rent increases, unreliable transit and an inaccessible permitting process may each matter to solving the problem.

Make the disagreement usable

Start by making the task concrete. Agree on what needs to happen, then ask each person what they see that the others might miss. Which claims can the group check? Which trade-offs depend on values or on who absorbs the cost? Give people room to revise a view without demanding that they adopt the rest of your politics.

Some differences will persist. The goal is enough trust and clarity to make a decision together, then judge it by what happens to the people it was supposed to serve.

Read next

All writing